MEPS 452:287-295 (2012)  -  doi:10.3354/meps09655

NOTE
Distinction between effective pattern-based and selection-based biodiversity surrogates is essential: caveats for managers

Serge Andréfouët1,*, Mélanie A. Hamel1,2, Mayeul Dalleau1,3 

1Institut de Recherche pour le Développement, Centre de Nouméa, BP A5, 98848, Nouméa, New Caledonia
2Present address: Australian Research Council Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies, James Cook University, Townsville, Queensland 4811, Australia
3Present address: Kélonia, 46 rue du Général de Gaulle, 97436 Saint Leu, La Réunion—France

ABSTRACT: Ecological concepts and data may justify the selection of biodiversity conservation plans among different options, but can also lead to poor conservation guidelines if not properly used. The use and meaning of the ‘surrogate’ concept in ecology and conservation planning contexts is a typical example. Surrogates are entities such as species, environmental variables or habitats, which are used to represent a target entity such as genes, species, ecosystems or related metrics. ‘Pattern-based surrogacy’ identifies effective surrogates using statistical congruence, while ‘selection-based surrogacy’ identifies effective surrogates through a notional conservation plan or prioritization analysis where sites are added to a set of protected areas, often using a complementarity criterion between sites. With this clear framework in mind, an investigation of the coral reef literature revealed that most published studies on surrogates of reef biodiversity refer in fact to pattern-based surrogates. Fundamentally, there is nothing wrong with both approaches. However, efficient pattern-based surrogates are often recommended for conservation planning, implying that they could be efficient selection-based surrogates. In fact, efficient pattern-based surrogates are not necessarily efficient selection-based surrogates and vice versa. The reason is the complementarity rules used by selection algorithms. We call for more clarity from authors on the context in which effective surrogates have to be used, and more caution from managers when surrogates are to be used in conservation plans.


KEY WORDS: Surrogacy · Surrogate effectiveness · Remote sensing · Conservation planning · Habitat map · Coral reefs


Full text in pdf format 
Cite this article as: Andréfouët S, Hamel MA, Dalleau M (2012) Distinction between effective pattern-based and selection-based biodiversity surrogates is essential: caveats for managers. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 452:287-295

Export citation
Mail this link - Contents Mailing Lists - RSS
- -