ESEP

Ethics in Science and Environmental Politics

A diamond Open Access journal, ESEP presents, discusses and develops issues concerning ethics in science and environmental politics, and in ecology and economics.

Online: ISSN 1863-5415

Print: ISSN 1611-8014

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3354/esep

Impact FactorNot assessed by JCR

Article Acceptance Rate40% (2024)

Average Time in Review200 days (2024)

Total Annual Downloads56.447 (2025)

Volume contents
Ethics Sci Environ Polit 13:131-139 (2014)

Framing the university ranking game: actors, motivations, and actions

ABSTRACT: Any formulation of the university ranking game involves the perspectives of the 3 key actors: (1) graduating high-school students, (2) universities, and (3) ranking publications. These university rankings are developed and maintained by for-profit publications or magazines, which must balance 2 potentially conflicting motives: (1) to provide students with information to help them decide which university to attend and (2) to increase the revenues of the publication. The actions of the students involve their decision on which universities to apply to and which university to attend among those they are admitted to. The universities seek to attract the best students and seek to improve their ranking to do so. We frame these diverse motives and the ensuing actions of these 3 sets of actors as the university ranking game and discuss the potential inefficiencies in the game and the possibility for unethical behavior by publications and universities.

KEYWORDS

James A. Dearden (Corresponding Author)

  • Department of Economics, Lehigh University, Bethlehem, PA 18015, USA
jad8@lehigh.edu

Rajdeep Grewal (Co-author)

  • Department of Marketing, Smeal College of Business, Penn State University, University Park, PA 16802 USA

Gary L. Lilien (Co-author)

  • Department of Marketing, Smeal College of Business, Penn State University, University Park, PA 16802 USA